Google

Demonstration of Microscale Projection Experiments - Chemistry en miniature

Light Absorbance of Triphenylmethylium Salts


Peter Keusch





German version



Chemicals: 10 - 4 M aqueous solution of crystal violet
10 - 3 M aqueous solution of malachite green
triphenylcarbinol
conc. sulfuric acid


Hazards and safety precautions:

Crystal violet may cause cancer. Severe eye irritant. Harmful by inhalation, ingestion and through skin contact.
Malachite green is harmful if swallowed. Contact with skin or eyes may cause irritation.
Conc. sulfuric acid is highly toxic. Causes severe burns. May be fatal if swallowed. May cause cancer through inhalation. Very destructive of mucous membranes.

Safety goggles, protective gloves and effective ventilation required.


Experimental procedure:

Three test tubes are prepared as described in the following table:

Test tube 1
  2 crystals of triphenylcarbinol  
Test tube 2
  1 mL solution of crystal violet  
Test tube 3   1 mL solution of malachite green  


1 mL of conc. sulfuric acid is added to the triphenylcarbinol crystals in T1.





Results:

Color Absorption Maximum
Test tube 1 orange-yellow 431 nm
Test tube 2 violet 590 nm
Test tube 3 green-blue 623 nm


Foto
Photo:  Triphenylmethyl Cation    crystal violet    malachite green



Discussion:

·   Triphenylmethanol is insoluble in water, but when it is treated with concentrated sulfuric acid, it dissolves to create a bright yellow solution. A colored species, the triphenylmethyl cation, is formed reversibly  (1).  It can be isolated with weakly nucleophilic ions (i.e. BF 4 -, SbCl 6 -).


The center of carbocation is in conjugation with three benzene rings. The positive charge is strongly de-localized. Thus the triphenylmethyl cation possesses ten resonance structures, in which the positive charge is distributed on six ortho and three para positions.

·   The extent of the bathochromic shift increases in the order  triphenylmethyl cation  <  crystal violet  <  malachite green   (2).  The position of the absorption maxima of the mentioned triphenylmethanes depends on the geometry of the chromophore and on the character of he (para-) substituents on the phenyl rings.



·   X-ray studies indicate that the geometrical structure of crystal violet (like triphenylmethyl cation) resembles a three-bladed propeller. The planes of the phenyl rings are twisted out of the plane defined by the central carbon atom and its three bonds. The dihedral angle between the phenyl rings and the central coordination plane is 27.7°. The twisting can be understood as a compromise between the effect of p-electron conjugation and the ortho-ortho steric repulsion involving aromatic hydrogens on adjacent rings. The p-electron conjugation (maximum resonance stabilization) favours a planar conformation. The steric interaction between the ortho-hydrogen atoms favours a non-planar structure  (Fig. 2).  Due to the non-planar structure, the p-electron conjugation in crystal violet is not so extensive as in a p-conjugated planar sytems.



Fig. 1: Ring twisting
steric repulsion of ortho hydrogen atoms (blue)

             

            Oppositely twisted enantiomeric conformations of crystal violet ion

·   Unlike crystal violet, malachite green has only two out of three phenyl rings substituted with dimethylamino groups. The two substituted rings are nearly planar aligned. The degree of p-electron conjugation between the two coplanar rings  (2)  is at a maximum. Hence the absorption maximum of malachite green is shifted to the longer wavelengths in the visible region of the spectrum. The third aromatic ring does not enter into the resonance and is therefore turned out of the plane of the other two rings.


Reference:
Computer-Interfaced Experiments   Absorption Maxima of Triphenylmethane Dyes
Microscale Projection Experiments   Light Absorption of Triphenylmethane Dye
Computer-Interfaced Experiments   Kinetics: Fading of Triphenylmethane Dyes - Pseudo First Order Reaction
Computer-Interfaced Experiments   Kinetics: Fading of Phenolphthalein in Alkaline Solution
Microscale Projection Experiments   Crystal Violet - a pH Indicator
  Demonstration Experiment on Video   Crystal violet - a pH Indicator


General experimental instructions and index of experiments






Site Meter